Ravi Shastri mentioned in his post-match analysis that it is time for India to move on from the Ganguly-Tendulkar opening partnership. I could not agree more with him.Move on to whom is the topic of a separate discussion. But I seriously hope we do not move on to a certain Gautam Gambhir.
Gambhir plays for Delhi in first class cricket where he has a reputation of tearing apart sub-standard bowling attacks a-la Virender Sehwag, his opening partner. He scores a lot of runs and he scores them quickly. But as it has been with many players, the step up to the next level has been not so easy for him.
Gambhir made his debut as an opener in a India - South Africa - Bangladesh triangular series just after India's fantastic World cup 2003 campaign. It was a series none of the seniors wanted to play and Gambhir got his break. It was not a lucky break though. He played 3 games against South Africa, and was snared by an away going delivery from Ntini each time. He crossed 20 only once against Bangladesh. This performance and the return of the starts saw his career taking a long 2 year hiatus.
His second innings, so to speak, started in the Dravid-Chappell era, when building a team with youngsters was the buzzword. He got his chance against Sri Lanka after India had already won the series. He made an impressive 100. But it has been slim pickings since then. His weakness of falling over while trying to play in front of his pads to the on-side has resulted in his downfall on a number of ocassions. And when it is not that, it is playing way outside his off-stump and getting caught by the keeper or the slips.
The worst of his dismissals came against South Africa at Hyderabad. This was back in the days when super-sub was part of the game. Gambhir was a super-sub in the game where India lost the toss and had to bat first. So his game was virtually over. But India lost it's way terribly and was reduced to 34/4. India gambled with using up the super-sub for a bowler. Out walked Gambhir to join Yuvraj. He was walking back to the pavilion after adding 1 run to his and team's tally. He had again fallen to a loose and flashy drive outside the off stump and was caught by the wicket keeper. This was the shot of a person who was not aware of the match situation.
And the numbers tell a very familiar story;
He has played a total of 26 games, scored 775 runs, at an average of 32.29, with 2 100s and 4 50s. Not a bad record for someone who has played that many games. But digging deeper reveals the true picture. Against the minnows (Bangladesh, Scotland, Ireland) he has played 6 games, scored 369 runs, at an average of 92.25, with 1 100 and 3 50s. Against the other teams (Sri Lanka, Pakistan, South Africa, England and West Indies) he has played 20 games, scored 406 runs, at an average of 20.3, with 1 100 and 1 50. Of the 24 times he has gotten out, 18 have been caught by wicket keeper or the slips, or bowled/lbw to the incoming ball. That is a staggering 75% of his dismissals.
And to add to this, he does not bowl, nor is he an exceptional fielder.
So the question I want to ask is, how many more times do we want to see him fail before deciding to move on? As far as I am concerned, we have already passed that time. Last season we suffered because of Greg Chappell's obsession with Suresh Raina. I just hope we don't do the same this season with Gambhir.
Robin Uthappa, who was the toast of the nation pre-WC has not played a single game since. The same guy who was picked ahead of Raina, Kaif and Gambhir is now sitting on the sidelines. Why?

